Editorial Policies

Nusantara Border Governance Review (NBGR) is a peer-reviewed, open access journal published by the Badan Nasional Pengelola Perbatasan (BNPP) of the Republic of Indonesia. The policies below follow the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, WAME) and the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). They apply to authors, editors, reviewers and the publisher.

Contents: 1. Journal identity · 2. Aims, scope and article types · 3. Publication schedule · 4. Ownership and editorial independence · 5. Peer review · 6. Publication ethics · 7. Authorship · 8. Artificial intelligence · 9. Conflicts of interest · 10. Plagiarism and similarity checking · 11. Research misconduct · 12. Corrections, retractions and expressions of concern · 13. Post-publication discussion and complaints · 14. Open access · 15. Copyright and licensing · 16. Fees (APC) · 17. Data availability · 18. Archiving and preservation · 19. Privacy · 20. Contact

1. Journal identity

  • Title: Nusantara Border Governance Review (abbreviation: NBGR)
  • Publisher: Badan Nasional Pengelola Perbatasan (BNPP), Republic of Indonesia
  • e-ISSN: [[in application — add the number and a link to https://portal.issn.org once issued; until then write "e-ISSN: in process"]]
  • Languages: English and Indonesian
  • Frequency: twice a year (see Publication schedule)

2. Aims, scope and article types

NBGR publishes original, peer-reviewed scholarship on the governance of state borders and border regions, including: border crossing posts (PLBN) and border management; maritime boundaries and the blue economy; cross-border communities; connectivity and trade corridors; and law and institutions of sovereignty. Comparative and international studies are welcome.

The journal accepts: research articles (original empirical or theoretical research), review articles (systematic or critical reviews), and policy analyses grounded in evidence. [[confirm the list and word limits, e.g. research article 6,000–9,000 words]]. At least 60% of the articles in each issue are original research articles.

3. Publication schedule

NBGR publishes two issues per volume (one volume per year), in June and December. Each issue contains at least 7 articles. Issues are numbered Volume (year) and Number (1–2). Accepted articles may be published online ahead of the issue date once final proofs are approved.

4. Ownership and editorial independence

NBGR is owned and published by BNPP. As publisher, BNPP is responsible for the journal's legal basis, funding, infrastructure and continuity. Operating costs are funded by BNPP, so authors are not charged.

Editorial decisions are independent. All decisions on manuscripts are made by the Editor-in-Chief, or by a Section Editor acting on the Editor-in-Chief's authority, based solely on academic merit and peer review. Decisions are free from interference by the publisher, government officials, funders or any other party. Editors are appointed for their academic qualifications, not ex officio. Manuscripts by BNPP officials or staff go through the same peer review process as all other submissions.

5. Peer review

  • Type: double-anonymous. Reviewers do not know the authors' identities, and authors do not know the reviewers' identities. Authors must remove identifying information from the manuscript and file properties.
  • Stages:
    1. Initial screening by the editors (1 week). This covers scope, completeness, compliance with author guidelines and a similarity check. Manuscripts may be declined at this stage without external review.
    2. External review by at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the topic (1–2 weeks), who are not from the authors' institution.
    3. Editorial decision: accept, minor revision, major revision, resubmit for review, or decline.
    4. Revision by authors (minor: 1 week; major: 2 weeks), with a response to each reviewer comment. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to reviewers.
    5. Final decision by the Editor-in-Chief, then copyediting, layout and author proof approval.
  • Review criteria: originality and novelty; relevance to the scope; soundness of theory, method and data; depth of analysis and synthesis; validity of conclusions; currency and primary nature of references; and clarity of writing.
  • Reviewers: reviewers hold a doctorate or equivalent research record in a relevant field, with recent publications in that field. Reviewers must keep manuscripts confidential, declare conflicts of interest, and follow the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
  • Target timeline: first decision within 60 days of submission.
  • Appeals: authors may appeal a decision once, in writing, to the Editor-in-Chief. The appeal is handled by an editor not involved in the original decision.

6. Publication ethics

NBGR follows COPE's Core Practices. Authors must submit original work that has not been published elsewhere and is not under consideration by another journal. Research involving human participants must have appropriate ethical approval and informed consent, and must protect participants' identities. Where research involves sensitive border-security information, authors must ensure that publication does not disclose classified or personal data.

7. Authorship

Authorship is limited to those who made a substantial contribution to the conception, design, data collection or analysis of the work. Each author must also have drafted or critically revised the manuscript, approved the final version, and agree to be accountable for the work. All authors must approve the submission. The corresponding author handles communication with the journal. Contributors who do not meet these criteria are acknowledged. Changes to the author list after submission require a written statement signed by all authors. Authors are encouraged to register an ORCID iD.

8. Use of artificial intelligence (AI)

  • Authors: AI tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot take responsibility for the work (COPE position statement). Authors who use generative AI for writing, translation, analysis or image creation must disclose the tool, its version and its purpose. This disclosure goes in the Methods section or a statement before the references. Basic spelling and grammar checking does not require disclosure. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of the entire manuscript, including AI-assisted content. AI-generated fabricated data or references are treated as misconduct.
  • Editors: editors must not upload manuscripts or reviewer reports to generative AI tools, because this breaches confidentiality. Editorial decisions are never delegated to AI.
  • Reviewers: reviewers are prohibited from uploading manuscripts, or any part of them, to generative AI tools, and from using such tools to write their reviews.

9. Conflicts of interest

Authors must disclose all financial and non-financial interests that could influence the work, including funding sources and institutional affiliations. Reviewers and editors must decline any manuscript where they have a conflict of interest, such as a recent collaboration, the same institution, or a personal or professional relationship. Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial team are handled by an independent editor, and the author has no access to the review. Members of the editorial team may publish at most one article per year in NBGR.

10. Plagiarism and similarity checking

Every submission is checked with [[similarity software, e.g. Turnitin / iThenticate]] before review and again before publication. Plagiarism, self-plagiarism, duplicate or redundant publication, and text recycling without citation are not accepted. Similarity reports are always assessed by an editor rather than judged on the percentage alone. As a guide, manuscripts with an overall similarity above [[20]]%, or more than [[3]]% from a single source (excluding references and quoted material), are returned to the authors or declined. Plagiarism discovered after publication is handled under section 12.

11. Research misconduct

NBGR takes allegations of fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, image manipulation, citation manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest and authorship disputes seriously. Allegations are handled according to the COPE flowcharts. Authors are given the opportunity to respond. Where necessary, the journal informs the authors' institutions. Possible outcomes include rejection, correction, retraction or an expression of concern.

12. Corrections, retractions and expressions of concern

  • Correction (erratum/corrigendum): published when an error affects part of an article but not its main findings.
  • Retraction: published when findings are unreliable, or when there is plagiarism, duplicate publication or unethical research. Retracted articles remain online, clearly marked "Retracted", with a linked retraction notice stating the reason, following the COPE Retraction Guidelines.
  • Expression of concern: may be issued while an investigation is ongoing.

Once an article is published, it is never altered silently.

13. Post-publication discussion and complaints

Readers may comment on or raise concerns about published articles by writing to the editorial office (see Contact). Substantive comments may be published as a letter to the editor, with the authors given the right to reply. Complaints about the journal's processes are acknowledged within 7 days and handled by the Editor-in-Chief. Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief are handled by the publisher's designated representative, without influence on editorial content.

14. Open access

NBGR is a fully open access journal. All articles are freely available to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search and link to the full text immediately upon publication. No subscription or registration is required. This follows the definition of the Budapest Open Access Initiative.

Authors retain copyright of their articles and grant NBGR the right of first publication. Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). Anyone may share and adapt the work for non-commercial purposes, provided the original authors and NBGR are properly credited and adaptations are distributed under the same license. Authors may deposit any version of their article in institutional or subject repositories, with a link to the published version.

16. Fees (Article Processing Charges)

NBGR charges no fees of any kind. There are no submission fees, article processing charges (APC) or publication fees. All costs are covered by BNPP.

17. Data availability

Authors are encouraged to make the data underlying their findings available in a public repository and to include a data availability statement. Where data cannot be shared, for example because it involves restricted security information or personal data, the statement must explain why and describe how the data may be accessed by qualified researchers, if at all.

18. Archiving and preservation

All published content is stored on the publisher's servers with regular backups. [[After the e-ISSN is issued: "NBGR content is preserved through the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN)." — do NOT add LOCKSS/CLOCKSS or PKP PN until it is actually active.]] Authors may also self-archive as described in section 15.

19. Privacy

Names and email addresses entered on this site are used only for the purposes of the journal and are not shared with any other party. See the Privacy Statement.

20. Contact

Editorial Office, Nusantara Border Governance Review
Badan Nasional Pengelola Perbatasan (BNPP)
[[full physical address, city, postal code]]
Email: [[institutional address, e.g. jurnal.nbgr@bnpp.go.id]]
Telephone: [[number]]

Last updated: [[date of publication]].